The latest claim of outrage is regarding the keffiyeh - the israeli Keffiyeh that is.
The ZFA, the Zonist Freedom Alliance, has designed a keffiyeh with Stars of David in the design, and others have since designed similar keffiyehs, such as with the words Am Yisrael Chai along the side. They call it the "Israeli Keffiyeh".
The Israeli Keffiyeh seems to have become popular enough to draw the ire of the Palestinians. They are claiming that the Israeli Keffiyeh is a theft of the Palestinian heritage.
From INN:
”Palestinian culture must be preserved by organizing exhibitions and festivals to show that heritage claimed by Israel is actually Palestinian!” Bargouthi claimed in an interview with Ma’an Radio. "Palestinians" have often been asked to show what they claim their non pan-Arab heritage, since before the declaration of the state of Israe, the word "Palestine" or "Palestinian" referred to Jewish institutions, such as the "Palestine Post" and the "Palestine Philharmonic" and there was no Arab group calling itself by that name.
Barghouthi specifically mentioned the blue and white “Israeli keffiyeh” with a Stars of David pattern worn in Israel and on American university campuses by activists from the Zionist Freedom Alliance. The PA minister called the scarf a “Palestinian national symbol” and attacked Zionists for usurping the keffiyeh and replacing its traditional pattern with Zionist symbols.Benny Katz of the Zionist Freedom Alliance responded:
the ZFA headscarf carries a strong Zionist message. “In ancient times, it was common for Hebrews to wear keffiyot, but the rise of Islam brought with it a series of laws that gave non-Muslims an inferior position in society. Synagogues could not be built higher than mosques and Jews could not ride atop animals for fear that they would appear higher than Muslims. As the keffiyeh came to be seen as the crown of the Arabs and its wearer was attributed an honorable status, non-Muslims were forbidden from wearing such garments.”
“With the rebirth of the Jewish nation in our homeland, there are voices calling Israel back to our authentic national culture. The Israeli keffiyeh is part of this trend. Its wearer is making a clear statement that – like the Arab, Kurd and Druze – the Jew is a Middle Easterner and is indigenous to this region. The Israeli keffiyeh is a proud symbol of Jewish nationalism but also a statement of solidarity with the other peoples of the Middle East.”
“By wearing it, we proclaim a desire for peace with our neighbors balanced with an equally strong proclamation that our people have a legitimate right to sovereignty in our entire country. In today’s post-exile Jewish reality, we will no longer allow foreign antagonists to rob us of our homeland or of our national culture.”
Shemspeed, a Jewish music label and promotional company in the United States, recently released their own version of the ZFA’s Israeli keffiyeh, embroidered with the Hebrew words Am Yisrael Hai (The Nation of Israel Lives). According to Shemspeed founder and director Erez Safar, who also produces music under the alias of DJ Diwon, Jews have just as much right as Arabs to wear the keffiyeh.
“Jews indigenous to the [Middle East], such as my family, have worn some variation of the kefyah [cap/kippa] and keffiyeh for thousands of years… The original purpose of the scarves was to provide protection from the sun and sand. When it comes to religious observance, the Muslim tradition of head covering originates from the Jewish tradition.”
Cool. Where can I get one?
ReplyDeleteDitto what Pesky settler said
ReplyDeleteI love mine! I bought a little bag to match so I could keep stones in it...;-)
ReplyDeletehttp://shemspeed.com/thekef/
Hysterical idea.
ReplyDeleteDifferent strokes for different folks.
Forget the Kifiya - the Arabs may not realize that the Kippa Sruga (Knitted Kipa) was based on Arab Head Coverings.
ReplyDeleteIf I'm not mistaken, In the early days of the state (?) the Religious Zinists were looking for a type of hat that would differentiate themselves from the Charedi world and had a connection to Eretz Ysirael. The Knitted head covering of the local Arabs was a perfect example to mimic.
I am certainly not against Israelis enjoying Middle Eastern culture, but I am against dubious historical claims without any evidence, such as the assertion that the kaffiyeh is really being "reclaimed" as Jewish. Puh-leez. The rest of the statement, about Jews being indigenous to the Middle East (Israelis certainly are) is fine, but just making up stuff about what it was "common" for "Hebrews" to wear in "ancient times"?
ReplyDeletes -
ReplyDeletehow do you know the claim is being made up? do you know that they did NOT wear a keffiyah type headdress?
I love it. If it does nothing else but annoy the heck out of the arabs, I think it's hysterical
>how do you know the claim is being made up? do you know that they did NOT wear a keffiyah type headdress?
ReplyDeleteIf they did, it's a lucky coincidence, and neither I nor her knows it.
Sure, we can speculate because of the sun and sand in the Near East that by gosh, the ancient Israelite might have also learned of the benefits of wearing a cloth to protect the head and eyes from the rigors of the weather. But there's no evidence of it, nor would it be a kaffiyeh, which *is* traditional Arab dress.
In fact this is nothing more than what the Europeans did in the early 19th century when they came to the Holy Land. They looked at the locals and retrojected everything they did onto the biblical past, imagining Bedouin culture to graphically and correctly depict the Bible in all its details, and they read the Bible in this light. Take a look at 19th century paintings of Bible scenes inspired by the Holy Land.
s -
ReplyDeleteI actually agree with you in principle. The Jews have throughout history borrowed style from their neighbors and claimed it as their own.
The point here though isn't really whether or not the keffiyah is ancient jewish. The point is whether or not the claim to the keffiyah will annoy the Arabs.
First israel STEAL palestinian land, Now it`s the palestinian keffiyeh, When will it ever end ? No im not a palestinian just a Englishman who thinks israel is going to far. thank you.
ReplyDelete