In that vein we now have another interesting psak.
From INN:
Soldiers in Gaza could eat meat during the coming days, the IDF Rabbinate announced Monday.
The decision contravenes a widely-held Ashkenazi Jewish custom not to eat meat from the beginning of the Hebrew month of Av – which began Monday – until after the Fast of the Ninth of Av next week, during the period generally known as the "Nine Days." Sephardi Jews refrain from the start of the week in which the Ninth of Av occurs.
The ban on eating meat, except for Shabbat meals, is a long-standing one, instituted after the Destruction of Jerusalem and the exile of the Jewish people from the Land of Israel, as a sign of mourning for the Destruction.
Other customs prevalent during this period include not taking haircuts or shaving, not listening to music, and not attending parties or going to places of entertainment.
While soldiers are not exempted from the ban on haircuts or shaving – most don't have a chance to shave at the front anyway, said the Rabbinate – they could eat meat if they felt the need.
Meat supplies protein and vitamins that are very difficult to get otherwise, especially under battlefield conditions, the Rabbinate said – and since soldiers need their energy and strength to fight Hamas terrorists, they were permitted to eat meat.
However, those who felt they could manage without meat were certainly not obligated to do so, the Rabbinate added.
------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------
Arutz Sheva erred when they said:
ReplyDelete"Sephardi Jews refrain from the start of the week in which the Ninth of Av occurs."
Really, Sepharadi Jews refrain from meat starting from the 2nd of Av through the entire 10th day of Av.
Re: music, the Sepharadi custom is the same as the Ashkenazi custom - the entire 3 weeks.
Shavu'a Shehal Bo applies to haircuts and shaving, showering, laundering, etc.
Mi dinah de gemara, one can eat meat right up to Erev Tisha B'Av. Although the Ashkenazi custom is to be stringent from Rosh Chodesh, there are exceptions, such as for the sick or for pregnant ladies, who have a need for meat. So it is not clear to me that such are even within the original minhag at all.
ReplyDeleteI should add that pickled meat one could eat even on Erev Tisha B'Av mi dinah de gemara, although our minhag is not to even from Rosh Chodesh. Maybe the soldiers would enjoy some nice hot corned beef!
ReplyDelete"The ban on eating meat, except for Shabbat meals, is a long-standing one, instituted after the Destruction of Jerusalem and the exile of the Jewish people from the Land of Israel, "
ReplyDeleteI guess that since the middle ages came after the destruction of Jerusalem this statement is technically true. As some scholars have shown the minhag arose much later due to a misreading/emendation.