Interestingly, just nearly a year ago the rav of the police forces proposed a similar change and Chief Rabbi Dovid Lau gave his blessings to it. I dont know why it needs to be requested again, but perhaps it was not then widely adopted or officially changed.
I looked in my Koren siddur and it says "soldier of the IDF and the security forces". My Artscroll siddur doesn't have the prayer at all, though if I remember correctly the RCA edition of the Artscroll siddur does, though I dont have it to check the text.
To be a bit "Reb Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev", how wonderful is it that a secular minister in a secular government of a largely secular state is concerned that the police should be included in the people's prayers.. this did not (I do not know why not) come from a religious/Haredi minister or member of government or from a rabbi at any level but from a secular minister.... one can criticize and point to this or that speech and say they left God out of the picture and it is clearly belief in our own powers, or one can see that even if they do not always say it, they still seem to believe it...
------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------
He learnt in Netiv Meir Yeshiva high school in Jerusalem, so he probably knows a bit.
ReplyDeleteYes, the RCA edition of the Artscroll siddur does have the prayer.
ReplyDeleteBut probably the old version.
DeleteIt's probably just a matter of new siddurim being published. If more and more shuls begin buying the Koren (or if there's a new edition of the Rinat Yisrael), then people will say it. I imagine many shuls already do. It's not like the changes- there are two, in fact, the other ("b'chol makom she-hem") to include international operations, including the Mossad- are secret. Probably secular people haven't heard of them.
ReplyDeleteI'm not in favor of getting too specific. One guy in my shul- who's very involved in Ichud Hatzala- actually throws them in to. (You can see his use of "hatzala" to include all rescue services, but I don't think it's a coincidence.) He throws in a few other categories as well, like "intelligence." I think it just sounds awkward. What's next, the Fire Department and Prison Service?
civil servants too!
Delete