Sep 30, 2021

scoffing at the hechshers on bleach

In a Knesset Committee session today discussing the proposed kashrut reforms of Minister Matan Kahane, Committee head MK Yulia Malinovsky (Yisrael Beyteynu) explained some of the reforms proposed and the need for them and then scoffed somewhat at the current situation - she held up examples of bleach and dishwashing soap and other such items showing how they have kashrut supervisions even though they are not food and there is no need for kashrut on such items.

Of course the Haredi MKs and media are taking it personally and upset at her and at Kahane for her scoffing, even though really she is right. For the companies it is marketing to get these certifications even on products that dont need it because so many people have been brainwashed to believe they need hechshers even on such items.

The problem is that as far as I can tell, the proposed reforms will not solve this problem. These are almost always done by private hechshers such as the Badatz Eida Hachareiidis and others, and not by the Rabbanut. The reforms are going to give the private hechshers more power, not less, so I dont see how the reforms will put an end to this type of behavior. That being the case, if I am correct, she should not have been scoffing at it because the proposed reforms will not solve this issue and put an end to that absurd situation. If they would be putting n end to it, then she would be able to laugh at it and show how necessary the reforms are, but that is not the case.


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

3 comments:

  1. I agree with you that the reforms as presented so far don't seem to solve this problem. That doesn't mean there isn't merit in bringing attention to an issue, when discussing legislation that is meant to address that issue.

    OTOH, the windshield wiper fluid I use in my car, only has a rabbanut hashgacha on it. It doesn't even have a KLP.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. no cleaning your windshield during the holiday!

      Delete
    2. Osher Ad sells it over Pesach. Perhaps it doesn't need a KLP hashgacha. ;)

      Delete