People are saying all sorts of things about Netanyahu and how the Left beat Netanyahu (in this round). That is the story of the past few days.
But that isnt the story.
The Left may have beaten Netanyahu this time, but did they win the battle and lose the war? Was the war ever even winnable when they went to battle with the weapons they used?
Will anyone ever really have control of the State, no matter who is running the country? If the Left should ever take the reigns back, the rightists will protest any significant legislation by threatening to not serve Reserve duty, to encourage pulling money and investment out of Israel, they'll block traffic and bring the masses out. Whoever becomes Prime Minister form the Right and tries to pass significant legislation will meet with more protests from the Left with businesses threatening to leave the country reservists refusing to serve, protests of masses, and all the rest.
How do we move forward from here, after all these lines were crossed? Netanyahu might have lost the battle, but I worry Israel has lost the war. Netanyahu might be the loser right now, but I worry that at the end of the day the tactics used mean we all have lost.
------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------
Everything is about demographics. In the last 2-3 generations the secular left had 1-2 children. The secular right had 2-3, the Sephardim had 3-4 and the religious had 6-12. Thus this situation is inevitable - the people who think they're the only qualified ones to run the country and that the country can only exist if they control it are now the minority and a shrinking one at that. And they may have a point consider a chunk of that majority would run the country into the ditch if they ever got control. But still, this is going to get worse as the shrinking minority gets more desperate to maintain control over the majority while trying to ignore the implications.
ReplyDeleteThe second most common flag at these demonstrations was the rainbow one.
DeleteMaybe if they wanted to improve their demographics, they could start by stopping the encouragement of sexual deviance among their youth.
I might add, sadly that some who I daven/learn with have made IMHO statments in poor tase like "See? Israel never sould have happened in the first place, Satmar had the right idea, secular Israel is not Eretz Yisroel". These are not NT guys, but Yeshivish and otherwise quite reasnable people. The idea that they see the failure as a positive makes me sick, sad and mad. This lack of Achdus will, and always has been our undoing.
ReplyDeleteI have been hearing things like this plenty here in Israel over the past couple of months, and especially the past few weeks
DeleteI've seen it, but it's really bizarre. These people need to be slapped. Maybe if the charedim hadn't decided to check out of the project from day one things would have been a lot different.
DeleteClarification, I am in the USA. As if I or we here have the right to an opinon w/o being on the ground there. Sigh...
ReplyDeletePeople blaming Israel for anti-Semitism is like people blaming the seatbelt for giving them a bruise after a bad car accident.
ReplyDeleteFrom US Agudah -Am Echad Urges Respectful Conversation and Consensus in Israel
ReplyDeleteI wonder if they cleared this Agudah in Israel?
KT
They like to pretend they're the same organization, but of course they're not.
Delete