Apr 19, 2017

Deri's crocodile tears over Shabbos desecration

After Minister of Interior Aryeh Deri did not come to a conclusion with what to do regarding the request of Iryat Tel Aviv, the Supreme Court has decided to allow the City of Tel Aviv to approve the opening of more kiosks and supermarkets on Shabbos

Deri got the government to transfer the power to decide on this issue back to him, after a previous minister transferred it to a committee due to a supposed conflict of interests. Deri requested more time right before the deadline for his decision, but the courts never agreed and Deri let it slide, supposedly thinking they would approve it at the last minute.

Now Deri, and his peers in the Haredi parties, are upset with the court decision. They are threatening to design and pass laws that will circumvent the Supreme Court decision and ban the commerce on Shabbos.

I don't have a concrete opinion on this Shabbos law - for or against. In general I think religious laws do more harm than good, but I understand the Jewish nature of the State needs to be protected somehow - I just don't know how and am not sure passing secular laws forcing secular people to keep religious laws is the right way to go about it.

Either way, no matter which way I lean on that issue on any particular day, I do not feel bad at all for Deri and his co-parliamentarians. They had the power in their hands, and they let it slip through their grasp. I don't know if he is expressing his anger for show, and he is probably more relieved than angry that he did not have to make a decision, either way, that would surely anger so many people, or if he is sincere in his anger post-facto.

Either way, no matter if he is sincere or not, this is his fault. While I am not sure if he did the right or wrong thing, his tears now are more of the crocodile variety, because if he really cared and opposed it he would have declined the petition when he had the ability to.

------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

3 comments:

  1. It is unfortunate that the issue of small business operating on Shabbat is regarded as a Religious Issue. The people least affected by this law are people who observe Shabbat - they would never work and probably never shop in small grocery stores in Tel Aviv, especially not on Shabbat.

    The victim of the court decision will be small business owners, often traditional Mizrachim, many of whom would prefer to spend Shabbat with their families, but if their competition is open on Shabbat they will be forced to also give up Shabbat with their families if they want to stay in business.

    It should be the Labour party looking out for working class small business owners in Tel Aviv, not the Religious parties. Unfortunately once it is defines as a "religious" issue and people start talking about religious coercion and the Stats-Quo, the battle lines are drawn and everyone must follow the party line, and the business owners (and their families) most affected by this law are completely forgotten.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. +1 This is what happens with liberalism is more important to leftists than the socialist aspect.

      Delete
  2. And we all know how hard it is for Deri to produce tears, genuine or otherwise. Time to roll out the onion Bisli.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...