Feb 14, 2022
Cash is not king
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Mar 13, 2018
Cash is no longer king
That law proposal passed last night.
cash is, officially, no longer king.
The law will go into effect on January 1, 2019, and it will apply equally to open checks 6 months later on June 1, 2019, as these checks have many similarities to cash.
Some of the details of the new law:
- Breaking the new law and using cash or check above the limitations will be forgiven for the first 9 months after the law goes into effect, to give the public time to acclimate to the new rules
- any transaction worth more than 11,000nis for a business or 50,000nis for private - cannot be paid in cash, even partially.
- using cash to pay salaries, donations, gifts or loans: if the transaction is worth more than 11,000nis with no family relation, or 50,000nis with family relation, cash is out, even for part of the arrangement.
- open checks and third party checks are not to be used. The bank will not accept checks that are open, or third party checks with sums greater than 10,000nis that have already been transferred through more than one party unless all the names and id numbers are listed on the check.
- businesses violating the law will suffer financial sanctions. Private individuals will receive criminal fines.
The law passed its final readings in Knesset 49-9.
source: Haredim10
I am not sure how they will enforce this, at least at a private level. Businesses seem easier, via the tax authorities and audits, but private donations or gifts can easily be split up into multiple donations, each being under the limit. Maybe if they discover multiple donations or gifts at just under 11k within a certain time frame they will consider it a violation.
Initially I thought this would be very damaging to free loan gemachs, and eventually it will be, but it seems MK Moshe Gafni (UTJ) has found a way to somewhat protect the Gemachs.
According to Kikar, banks and financial institutions under the supervision of the money laundering authorities will be exempt from this law. Gafni succeeded in getting the gemachs included in this exemption for a period of two years, even though they are not supervised by the relevant authorities. Gafni wanted them completely exempt, like banks and other institutions, but compromised on a two year exemption. I am sure when the time comes up, Gafni will make sure to get it extended.
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Jul 28, 2022
CheckPoint Software is kosher for portfolios
This is another in a series of articles about Israel-based
companies that appear to be a potential investment opportunity. People ask me
my opinion when I speak to community and business groups how they can best help
Israel and participate in the growth of the startup nation? Always consult your
broker, lawyer, and accountant before making investments. Read the full article
https://www.gurufocus.com/news/1836221/check-point-software-the-future-of-cybersecurity
Disclaimer: Please be advised that
neither the author or Life in Israel, its affiliates, its employees or agents
accept liability for any errors, omissions or damages caused by this
communication or its attachments, or which may otherwise arise as a result of
this communication transmission. Dr. Harold Goldmeier, Business Teacher
and Consultant
Summary
- Check Point
produces excellent margins and is a profitable stalwart in the
fast-growing cybersecurity industry.
- Its market
cap is up to over $16 billion through organic sales growth rather than
M&As.
- The company
finished the last quarter holding $3.8 billion in cash and equivalents.
- I predict a
double-digit increase in the share price given the company's long-term
potential.
Among
the more established leaders in the fast-growing cybersecurity industry is the
Israeli-American Check Point Software Technologies Ltd (CHKP, Financial).
Check Point has impressive margins, and I believe its conservatively managed
balance sheet, in combination with its leading cybersecurity technologies and
established market present, could help propel the company and its shares even
faster than the overall industry in the coming years.
Market
growth
Cybersecurity
is the future of defense. Governments, businesses, medicine, transportation and
every other computerized service will not survive the migration to the cloud
without sufficient data protection. Fortune Business Insights claims the global
cybersecurity market is on track for a CAGR of 13.4% to surpass $376 billion by
2029.
Company
profile
Check
Point’s business plan is neat and to the point; it develops, markets and
supports network, endpoint and data cybersecurity software. Services include
management and organization assessments, solutions and training. Its primary
target sectors are 50% software and 38% internet software services.
Management
tends to be conservative in its approach to business. For instance, Check Point
has acquired just one company in the last five years, Avanan, in August 2021).
It has made a total of 17 acquisitions since its 1993 founding.
Check
Point would be able to aggressively pursue M&As if it so wished. In my
opinion, management is too conservative in this torpid period of inflation and
lower valuations.
Valuation
As
of this writing, Check Point's market cap is $16.36 billion. Short interest is
less than 2%. Shares sell for $124.06 apiece; this is about the midpoint
between that stock’s 52-week high of $149.62 and low of $107.85. The share
price has recently moved in concert with the stock market and tech stock
trends. It might climb to $140 per share range if interest peaks and the tech
market trembles abate?
Check
Point reported strong first-quarter results in April 2022. Revenue grew 7% year
over year, substantially beating the consensus estimate. Products and licenses
grew 6%, and security subscriptions were up 13.6% year over year. Quantum,
CloudGuard and Harmony products were best sellers in the first quarter.
The company finished
last quarter holding $3.8 billion in cash and equivalent. Its gross profit
margin is 87.67%. The net income margin is 36.43%. Check Point’s margins are
among the highest in the cybersecurity industry, and it is profitable. I am moderately bullish on Check Point, primarily
because the tech industry is volatile and Check Point has both an powerful
product lineup and a solid balance sheet.
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Aug 14, 2022
Israel, General Mills, and Your Money
Israel,
General Mills, and Your Money
A Guest Post by Dr Harold Goldmeier
This summary article is about business in Israel. Read
the full article here: https://www.gurufocus.com/news/1832439/why-general-mills-is-a-fulfilling-investment. People ask me my opinion when I speak to community and business
groups how they can best help Israel and participate in the growth of the
startup nation? Always consult your broker, lawyer, and accountant before
making investments. Visit GuruFocus.com for the original article.
Disclaimer: Please
be advised that neither the author or Life in Israel, its affiliates, its
employees or agents accept liability for any errors, omissions or
damages caused by this communication or its attachments, or which may
otherwise arise as a result of this communication transmission. Dr. Harold
Goldmeier, Business Teacher and Consultant
·
General Mills says ending a joint
manufacturing venture in Israel was a business decision, not a boycott. A slew
of products is in stores across the country.
·
General Mills could be a value opportunity despite trading near
its 52-week high.
·
The nature of the business and the hallmark dividend could
provide stability amid uncertainty.
Slow,
steady, safe
Not every decision is political though it seems that way
because of Israelis’ existential angst.
A company representative emphatically claims, “We
continue to sell our products in
Israel and look forward to continuing to serve Israeli
consumers with our other brand.” Nor is it wise for investors to let politics sway
investment decisions. A slew
of GIS products is in stores across the country.
General
Mills Inc. (GIS, Financial)
might seem a bit richly valued now that the stock trades near its 52-week high.
Yet, in my opinion, General Mills has the potential rise another 10% higher. By
the end of the new fiscal year, my price target for this stock is in the $82 to
$85 range. This is because of the combination of the food industry's defensive
nature and General Mills' solid dividend.
Food
industry stocks are one of the best consumer defensive investments in a volatile
market. The S&P Food and Beverage Select Industry Index was steady from the
pandemic outbreak through this month.
General
Mills in particular did well. General Mills' shares are up 22.5% over the last
12 months. They rose 35.5% in the past five years. The price-earnings ratio of
18.35 is lower than the average of 21 for its broader industry, although it is
higher than the average of 15 in the food products group. Its Beta rating is
0.15. Short interest is a scant 2.22%.
Inflation
and any remaining bumps in the supply chain might cause a 1% to 2% slip in
profit in the new fiscal year’s first and second quarters. Anticipated sales
increases of 4% to 5% should offset pressures on margins and profits.
Great
company packaging
General
Mills manufactures, markets and distributes name brands of baking products,
cereals, dough and pastries, fruit, ice cream, prepared meals, organic and
natural foods, pet foods and pizza. Its products sell in over 100 countries
across six continents.
Cereals
are the core business. Fruit bars, health bars and snacks are among its
fastest-growing targeted segments. The company points out its heat and eat
breakfast sandwiches as fast growers for their convenience and competition with
fast-food restaurants.
Finances
are stable
In
May, the company reported that its diluted earnings per share for the quarter
increased 98%, or 23% in constant currency, to $1.12. Net sales increased 5%
for the year. Organic sales for the quarter were 13% higher. Operating profit
for the full fiscal year was up 11%. Fiscal fourth quarter operating profit
rose 85% to $1 billion. Operating cash flow grew 11%.
The
pet foods segment of General Mills had 20% to 30% sales growth, compounded by
the July 2021 purchase of pet treat brands. In the fourth quarter, net pet food
sales grew 37% year-over-year to $610 million.
General
Mills has historically used debt to finance growth and pay solid dividends. Its
debt-to-equity ratio is 1.22. The company has been reducing debt, but with its
enormous market cap, it is unlikely to have trouble borrowing money. The debt
has been falling for five consecutive years.
Valuation
The
GF Score for General Mills is 78 out of 100. Though highly profitable (8/10),
the value rank is minimal (3/10). Momentum is moderate (6/10). Its growth rank
just 6/10.
Corporate
insiders sold almost one million shares as the price increased. Meanwhile,
hedge funds increased their holdings in each of the last three quarters. They
added 385.7 thousand shares in the fourth quarter alone.
General
Mills pays an attractive 2.78% forward dividend yield, which I believe adds
greatly to the value proposition.
Commitment
to shareholders
I
like General Mills as an investment opportunity.
The company’s products are sold almost everywhere in Israel. It
also commits to business sustainability making its packaging
eco-friendly and targeting zero waste and carbon footprint.
GIS has upward potential, pays a good dividend, and is
financially sound.
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
May 20, 2008
The latest email scam

Ever hear of the Nigerian email scam? If you have been using email anytime over the past 13 years or so, how could you not be familiar with it?
Jameel just forwarded to me the latest, most recent take-off of the Nigerian email scam.
---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Tue, May 20, 2008 at 5:20 PM
Subject: urgent
To: xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
From: PM Ehud Olmert
Greetings from Jerusalem
Before I introduce myself, I wish to inform you that this letter is not a hoax mail and I urge you to treat it serious. We want to transfer to overseas account (30,000.000 NIS) Thirty million New Israeli Shekels from a prime Bank here in Israel. I want to ask you, if you are not capable to quietly look for reliable and honest person who will be capable and fit to provide either an existing bank account or to set up a new Bank a/c immediately to receive this money, even an empty a/c can serve to receive this money, as long as you will remain honest to me till the end for this important business trusting in you and believing in God that you will never let me down either now or in future.
I am PM Ehud Olmert, presently the Prime Minister of Israel. Potentially in the course of an audit next week, it will be discovered that I have a floating fund in an account opened in the bank in 1990, in which I regularly deposited envelopes full of cash. I discovered that with the audit next week, if I do not get this money out urgently it will be forfeited for nothing.
The official owner of this account is my wife Aliza, a great artist and a resident of Jerusalem, who unfortunately never had any art skills, and it shows it what she produces.
While we would have claimed that the deposits were for artwork, no one believes that any more, as who would actually by her crap. No other person knows about this account or anything concerning it - yet.
The total amount involved is Thirty million New Israeli Shekels only [30,000.000.00 NIS] and we wish to transfer this money into safe foreigners account abroad. But while I know many foreigners who give me money, I don't know any foreigner who will keep their mouth shut; I am only contacting you as a foreigner because this money cannot be approved to a local person here, but to a foreigner who has information about the account, which I shall give to you upon your positive response. I am revealing this to you with believe in God that you will never let me down in this business, you are the first and the only person that I am contacting for this business, so please reply urgently so that I will inform you the next step to take urgently.
At the conclusion of this business, you will be given 40% of the total amount, 50% will be for us while 10% will be for the expenses both parties may incurred during this transaction. PLEASE, TREAT THIS PROPOSAL AS TOP SECRET.
I look forward to your earliest reply
Best Regards,
PM Ehud Olmert
Jerusalem, Israel
(of course, Turban Tip to Jameel)
Jan 29, 2014
Tax Authority might hit "shnorrers" who travel abroad
The "cash cow" that is the business of going abroad to "shnorr" donations might be coming to an end.
It might be good for some people - those who complain about being bombarded in shul in every major city with a Jewish community in the USA and Europe, and it might be bad for others - those who rely on it for their organizations and institutions or their personal needs, or it might be bad for everyone - those who give even though they complain might lose a tzedaka opportunity that literally comes right to them (though there will always still be plenty of local opportunities wherever they are)...
The director of the Tax Authority, Moshe Asher, said, not specifically about the "shnorrers", you have a person who travels 10 times a year, but by us he registered as earning minimum wage. Or, a person who has four apartments and does not report the rental income he brings in from them - and according to reports submitted he earns less than minimum wage.
Asher says the tax authority is working to identify the people who should be submitting reports as to their true income but are not. Based on many new parameters being taken into account, tens of thousands of possible tax evasion situations are being discovered, Asher said. People will soon begin receiving letters informing them to submit reports, and taxes will be collected for years that they were not paid.
source: The Marker
Kikar has taken Asher's words and concluded that the industry of shnorrers is now at risk.
Kikar spoke to a couple of people who are worried about the report and think it might affect them.
One person said he travels 12 times a year but barely makes a living, and has a very low salary. This person runs a chessed organization. He says he would have to start filing detailed reports of each trip, how much was spent, how much was collected, etc. - he says "[the organizations] are barely getting by as it is with the donations being down and the subsidies being cut, and now to add the requirement for reporting and bureaucracy?"
Another person said he travels for personal needs several times each year. He says shnorring might not be a respectable profession, but for many in the haredi community it is a basic need for subsistence. He says people in the community make do with the minimum because they dedicate their lives to Torah and spirituality and there are social pressures, such as marrying off kids, that require people to travel abroad frequently. He says he lives hand to motuh and is in debt just so that he can marry off his kids... he lives off his kollel stipend, and everything he collects goes to his kids and family, and now, half would go to the tax authorities. he wants the askanim of the haredi community to fight and prevent this.
I feel bad for them. it is tough going through such a major change, that will require serious change in the entire system, and might hurt a lot of people. However, this collecting of money and not reporting it is no different than any business. Nobody wants to pay taxes. People work hard for their money. There is no reason to expect that a business should have to pay a lot of money in taxes but other people should not.
As long as they were able to get away with it, more power to them. I dont think people should choose to live their lives lechatchila looking for handouts, but if thats what they choose and they can find a way to do it without being obligated to pay taxes or if they think they do not need to, that is their choice, their business. But I do not think it is wrong for the government to change the system. Until now they got away with it, because it was not regulated properly, but really they are no different than anyone else. Your average employee is living from paycheck to paycheck as well, many living in the red - that is not a reason to demand that the State let them not pay taxes. Obviously people will have to pay at the tax rate based on the income - if he is making such a small amount of money, as he claims, he will pay less taxes.
I feel bad for them, but I am not impressed with the complaint.
Apr 10, 2011
Emergency Terror Victim Fund - Daniel Viflic
USA Tax Deductible: Payable to "US Friends of Lema'an Achai", PO Box 532, Oceanside, NY 11572-0532, USA.
UK Tax Deductible: Payable to "British Friends of Lema'an Achai", c/o Nava Kestenbaum, 96 Rigby Street, Salford, Manchester, M7 4BQ, ENGLAND.
Canadian Tax Deductible: Payable to "Gates of Mercy Charity Fund", C/O Murray Shore, 31 Marwill Street, Toronto, Ontario, M3H 3L2, CANADA.
Israel Tax Deductible: Payable to "Lema'an Achai", The Lema'an Achai Center, 40/7 Nahal Lachish, Ramat Bet Shemesh, 99093, Israel.
David & Avrohom
------------------------------
David Morris, Rabbi Avrohom Leventhal
Tel: +972 2 9991553
Ramat Beit Shemesh
99093 ISRAEL.
Jun 16, 2015
Proposed Law: treating waiters like human biengs
Obviously a salary would also come out of the customer's pockets, in the form of higher prices, but overall I'd probably be happy to know how much my dinner actually costs and not have to decide on a tip when I am finished eating. Regardless of me, the customer, waiters and waitresses need to be treated properly as employees, with minimum wage guaranteed, with benefits, and with the responsibility of paying taxes. Like any other employee.
Another thing I always wondered about is cleaning ladies. Cleaning ladies is another industry that is mostly a cash business. They do not pay taxes, they do not get benefits. Yet, with cleaning ladies it has become well known that you are actually obligated to be paying them bituach leumi money in addition to the salary you pay them. Even if they do not bother filing taxes and reporting their income, they can, and sometimes do, sue later for the bituach leumi money. They should be salaried employees or registered freelances. They should have to pay taxes on their income. They should have to pay their own bituach leumi, just like any registered freelancer does. Or they should be employees, with taxes deducted, with minimum wage, with benefits, with bituach leumi, and whatever else it entails.
MK Dov Henin (Hadash) has proposed a law that would at least deal with the waiters and waitresses. Henin's law would require restaurant owners to pay waiters and waitresses [at least] minimum wage, and not count the tips as or towards their salary.
Studies show that waiters and waitresses generally get paid less than minimum wage and receive no social benefits.
source: Jpost
It's a good start. Pay the waiters. Pay the waitresses. Treat them like human beings working for a living.
Nov 11, 2013
Israel's move to a free market
-------------------------------------------------------------
Donate to the Schneider Hospital so I can run the Schneider benefit marathon..
Jan 21, 2018
bank branches closing across Israel
The warning says that as of March 14, 2018, my branch (Hapoalim in RBS) will be converted to a branch holding no cash and no clerk services. From that date and on, all relevant services will be provided via the self-service machines. Other direct channels to the bank, such as via Internet, telephone, and app, will continue to function and be available. When necessary, bank branch 692 (the central Bet Shemesh branch located in downtown Bet Shemesh) will be available for all clerical services.
This is a trend happening in all the bank chains all over Israel. They are closing and/or merging branches in order to consolidate and save money.
Personally, I hate going into the bank and avoid it as much as possible. I use the machines to deposit checks, as I get a lot of these through my business, and I use the online services. The only time I go into the bank is if I am sent a notice that I need to come in and pick up a problematic check that I deposited, or if they tell me I need to come in to sign something. Once every few years I also need to renew my credit cards.
The biggest problem I see with this is that half the times the various self-service machines are not functioning properly. Currently, they can be fixed or rebooted relatively quickly (not including Saturday nights and Sundays when the branch is closed), as I or someone else can go into the bank and let them know, but with no actual bank behind it with real people talking to customers, I can see it taking longer to get the machines fixed. Maybe they will keep a small branch open with some services still provided by clerks, such as mortgage services and the like, and that will keep bank people nearby.
Additionally, with everyone needing personal service in the entire city going to one branch, that place will be packed and will be impossible to use.
Another point is that closing a branch in lieu of online services in a largely Haredi neighborhood seems like a bad idea. While many/most people do have Internet and app access, many do not and they need the in-bank services for a lot of what they do.
I get why they are doing this but I don't like it, even though I don't like going into the bank anyway.
UPDATE: to clarify, the bank branch is not closing but they are putting an end to cash services. There will be no tellers for deposits and withdrawals. Other clerks and the various services they provide will still be functioning as they have until now
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Jul 26, 2010
Lemaan Achai needs you
Unfortunately, when Lema'an Achai has troubles, the most needy members of our community pay a terrible price.
Two years ago, when the stock markets crashed around the world, and an international economic crisis of then-unknown proportions shook every community and household around the world - Lema'an Achai's cash-flow projections suddenly became unrealistic. We faced the choice of making deep cuts in the number of impoverished families we help, or...well.. asking you for help.
We publicly explained the situation, and our supporters made incredible and selfless efforts to help us through that dark period.
We have not made any emergency appeals since then. Although the economic crisis is beyond that grim shock-point two years ago, it has continued to impact us.
Many local families who were entirely self-sufficient, have taken a severe blow. Unemployment, difficulties obtaining payments, spiraling debt, have hit the managing-ok-classes. Lema'an Achai therefore has more families calling for help than ever before. And many of the families now needing help, were once donors.
Friends, here's where we stand...
Lema'an Achai is 'leaking' at between 10-20% each month.
Which is to say, our approved 2010 budget has been leaping ahead of our actual fundraising/revenue.
Lema'an Achai has squirreled away a small reserve - which is now largely used up.
We are now faced with heart-wrenching decisions.
What to cut?
Every single family which receives help from Lem'an Achai desperately needs it. They are usually earning just 10% BELOW the (already dismally low) Israeli poverty line. These families lack food, clothes, utilities and shelter. They often have other multifaceted problems, for which Lema'an Achai is their one-stop-shop giving support and solutions.
Lema'an Achai is not solely in the hand-out business; our comprehensive aid and services includes long term planning with families. Fifty-nine families are currently participating in courses to up-grade their employment and earnings potential. Many other families are receiving critical therapy and financial & business development counseling, which cannot be simply stopped mid-way.
With one hundred and eighty families (over A THOUSAND local residents) currently obtaining our aid and unique Smart-Chesed support from Lema'an Achai - and more requests coming through weekly - we now need to tell around 30 families (nearly two hundred residents) that,
tragically, we cannot help them any further. No supplies of food, or assistance with utilities and other critical bills; and no more support to get through today's crisis or planning to avoid tomorrow's crisis.
No Help - and no Hope.
Before we do that, we are making this last-ditch appeal for your help.
We know that you already give generously to many wonderful causes.
We are asking that you now do even more.
Here's how:-
1. Buy some raffle tickets. For details: www.SmartChesed.org. (There, that was easy).
2. Take a deep breath, and make an exceptional one-time generous donation, to help us over this hump.
3. Sign up for a regular commitment. You know your projected earnings, Be"H, and can already calculate your ongoing maaser kesafim obligations. So, please make a horaat kevah or credit card ongoing commitment to Lema'an Achai.
4. Sponsor a Lema'an Achai program - we have almost 30 innovative programs, and several of these are still available to be named after a special person, in their honor or in their memory. Who do you know who merits the honor of an ongoing chesed program, in their name?
5. Any other ideas?! If you could help with fundraising ventures, please step forward. We have some great ideas, and I'm sure you do too. We need people to step up to the plate, and help implement these plans, hands-on.
Click on this link to make a donation (or ongoing commitment) now:
https://lemaanachai.org/donations.aspx
Call our 24/6 Donations Line: 02-99999.33
Or send your check to: Lema'an Achai, 40/7 Nahal Lachish, Ramat Bet
Shemesh, 99093, Israel.
You are welcome to send this on, with your personal recommendations, to your friends and family members, who could be interested to support Lema'an Achai, "the Jewel in the Crown of Ramat Bet Shemesh".
Tizku Lemitzvot,
David & Avrohom
Dec 13, 2017
Public transportation on Shabbos
According to Katz this will make public transportation cheaper and will also prevent the shared taxi system form closing down, as has recently been threatened by a decrease in business. These shared taxis will be able to work on Shabbos, and their "weekend" business will grow, the there will be no use of the rav kav on Shabbos - passengers will have to pay cash. According to Katz, not allowing use of the rav kav on Shabbos will avoid breaking the status quo.
source: Kipa and Kikar
I guess technically it is not a breech in the status quo because of the lack of use of the rav kav, but it seems to me to only be cosmetic, as really it is the government allowing and encouraging more public transportation. If all they care about is how it looks cosmetically, than I guess this will not be a problem.
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Nov 16, 2014
hatchet job on Rabbanut regarding wine serving at weddings
Basically, they are upset the wedding halls under the Rabbanut require wine to be either mevushal (cooked, pasteurized) or served by religious Jews (article refers specifically to some sort of a scam where one can pay the Rabbanut extra to send its own wine servers who are yeshiva students in need of some extra money).
The rabbinic prohibition against "secular Jews" pouring wine is a real prohibition, not made up by the Rabbanut as Hess claims in his op-ed. That being said, there are many leniencies and qualifications that can be applied - if the person is not entirely secular but keeps some mitzvos, if he is called a "tinok she'nishba", and others. When they can be used, how they can be used, are all matters up for debate and discussion.
And, that being said, if a mashgiach or if the Rabbanut is running a scam by which he gets his friends some cash-paying jobs and has a way to charge the family more money in the process, that needs to be stopped. Some official process must be in place for these situations.
From Ynetnews:
Rinat and Tom are going to get married this winter. They’ve been living together for three years and all of a sudden they decided that they had to get married right away. (Yes, I asked Rinat if she was pregnant and the answer was no, but she added a "smiley face" to her note, so who knows).
Be that as it may, a winter wedding is a challenge. They had dreamed of having a small wedding, but their families were pressuring them to have a more conventional affair, with the fancy hors d’oeuvres and full course meal.
The problem is that the fancy places operate only in the summer. In the winter, if you want a more glitzy kind of hall, they were warned, you have to hurry up and reserve it right away. So they’ve been running around like crazy these past few weeks, checking suitable venues.
"The food is your affair," they told their parents. "You can decide on the menu, but we’ll choose the alcohol. No need for you to bother about it, okay?" Even though they are students, they know about wine.
They found a hall, closed on the deal and, while talking over the menu, announced to the owner, with all due formality, that they would be bringing the wine on their own. Since the catering company has a kashrut certificate, they reassured the owner that they would be purchasing kosher wine, from a winery with supervision by the Chief Rabbinate, not the Conservative Movement, God forbid.
"Ah, but that’s not quite all there is to it," the wedding hall owner stammered, averting their gaze. He had had similar conversations with other couples, and he knew that it would be difficult to explain. "The Rabbinate has new regulations," he said. "Because my waiters and barmen are not Shabbat observant, I am only permitted to serve yayin mevushal (pasteurized wine)."
"What?" exclaimed the astonished Rinat and Tom.
You don’t need to be a sommelier to know that wine that has been pasteurized tastes like a pita that has been defrosted in a microwave oven. "But that’s the way it is," said the venue owner, "they have a monopoly."
The Orthodox interpretation of Halacha is very strict about the rules governing wine production. A non-Jew cannot take part in the process. Any winery that has been certified kosher by the Rabbinate is forbidden from employing non-Jews in any function whatsoever that requires coming into contact with the grapes, the barrels, and naturally, the wine itself.
Furthermore, Israel’s Rabbinate has added more stringent restrictions and ruled that Jews who do not observe the mitzvot are also considered non-Jews in this context, and are not permitted to touch the wine at any point during the production process. If they do, the winery will not be granted a kashrut certificate.
You could be a qualified, professional vintner at a winery such as Carmel Mizrachi or Recanati, circumcised and the son of a Jewish mother, who not only served in an elite IDF unit but also had a bar mitzvah, but if you are secular you cannot touch a single barrel of wine in your winery.
The supervisor (mashgiach) appointed by the Rabbinate will follow your every step, making sure that you do not touch anything, deliberately or unintentionally. If you want to taste the wine from one of the barrels – something that vintners do as a matter of course and as part of their professional duties – the mashgiach will have to pour it for you.
If you, the vintner or the winery owner, are secular, or a non-Jew, or both, it doesn’t really matter. You are simply disqualified. Racist? Arrogant? Nauseating? Indeed, but so what? Until this monopoly is challenged from without, why should any of this change?
Now the madness has filtered into the wedding hall industry.
You have two choices, the hall owner explained to Rinat and Tom. Either you serve yayin mevushal (wine that has been cooked, after which, according to Orthodox interpretation, even a Gentile or a secular Jew can serve it to your guests), or pay the Rabbinate to send barmen of their own (at a cost of a few hundred shekels each) and they will send trustworthy Jews, yeshiva students who want to make some money because the allowance they receive is insufficient. They will serve the wine at your affair.
Then, and only then, will you be permitted to serve kosher wine that is not pasteurized.
By the way, they are not so strict about this in the hotels, the hall owner explained, because they are backed by the strong hotel association lobby. But for us, the caterers and wedding hall owners, they have made the rules more stringent.
They also know that the wedding business is a money-making industry. And most of the couples pay, because who wants to serve cooked wine at their wedding?


