Featured Post

Free The Hostages! Bring Them Home!

(this is a featured post and will stay at the top for the foreseeable future.. scroll down for new posts) -------------------------------...

Jan 4, 2023

Ben Gvir's visit to Har Habayit continues to make waves

The anger and eruption over Minister Ben Gvir's ascent to Har Habayit the other day continues and has yet to subside. In addition to all the international fallout, including countries that are supposedly friends of ours appealing to the United Nations to investigate or apply sanctions and whatnot, internally there has been a lot of criticism and comment from the Knesset, both Opposition and from members of the coalition.

The day of the event, I think was expected. Maybe even the next morning. Now, a couple of days later and this is still one of the top topics of discussion in Israel is a bit surprising, and it makes me wonder if this is going to snowball into something bigger.

Two comments from Coalition members in particular stood out for me. When coalition members, especially in what has been considered the most homogenous coalition ever where they are supposed to be working in harmony and they each already knew each other well, all the detriments and all the good things, so nothing was unexpected, criticize each other, that points to something bigger. Besides for just the discomfort of criticizing people you are supposed to work with hand in hand, this especially sharp criticism is unusual because they breed bad feelings amongst each other and then they can each be less forthcoming on other issues they were supposed to be working together on.

The two comments that struck me as more interesting are from MKs from UTJ.

Deputy Minister Uri Maklev said "there is a prohibition against going up to Har Habayit. Ben Gvir today is not a private Member of Knesset but is the Minister of National Security of the Land of Israel and he represents the entire public and has double responsibility. It is prohibited to provoke the nations, this is not how we show governance.

MK Yaakov Asher (UTJ) said "Ben Gvir going up to Har Habayit was superfluous, there is no benefit and we are taking this very seriously.

First of all, they knew who they were getting into bed with. Ben Gvir going up to Har Habayit should not have shocked anybody. I wonder if they (TUJ and maybe also Shas, as they are the ones most strongly opposed on a day to day basis to what Ben Gvir does) had a meeting before the government was formed to figure out and plan what to do when Ben Gvir does his various "provocations". 

Second, Asher says it was superfluous and sans benefit. Maybe to him who sees no value in going to Har Habayit. Ben Gvir does see value, both from a religious perspective and from a political perspective in taking a stand on the most important place to the Jewish people.

Third, Maklev talks about responsibility and that is all fair enough. I see it differently, but that is a fair position. I suspect Ben Gvir does as well. I think Ben Gvir sees it more of a responsibility to go and make sure Israeli control over Har Habayit gets stronger and the rights of Israelis on the Mount be expanded.

Fourth, I find it interesting, though it might actually be meaningless, that Maklev said Ben Gvir is a minister f Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel, rather than saying a Minister of Medinat Yisrael, the State of Israel. It might be meaningless but it jumped out at me.

Fifth, and last, and this is an old dispute, Maklev said provoking the nations is prohibited and is not how to show governance. While perhaps it would be better to not "provoke the nations" but anything we do provokes the nations. Our very existence provokes the nations, or being in Israel, our having a state, our presence, our mere being, all provokes the nations. And I dont think standing down in the face of threats is much of showing governance.






------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

1 comment:

  1. It's like when the Satmar Rebbe tried to blame anti-Semitism on Zionism, as if it had never existed before.
    It's a bit rich for a community that parastically sucks off the rest of the country while provoking them to outrage every second day to suddenly start worrying about the national interest and not provoking others.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...