Life in Israel

Featured Post

Free The Hostages! Bring Them Home!

(this is a featured post and will stay at the top for the foreseeable future.. scroll down for new posts) -------------------------------...

Dec 9, 2020

Interesting Psak: Lighting Menora in an Outdoor Minyan

Rav Shmuel Shapira, the rav of Kochav Yair, was asked if nowadays with so many people davenign in outdoor minyanim rather than in shuls, can one, should one, light the menora, chanukiya, with a bracha, in the outdoor  minyan, as would normally be done in shul?

Rav Shapira responded explaining that the mitzva of lighting the Chanukah menora is in one's house. The concept of lighting the menora in shul is a minhag to accomplish pirsumei nissa, publicizing the miracle, even though there was never a rabbinic decree to light in shul.

Reasons given for this minhag include:
1. for the benefit of guests without a home to light in, similar to the custom of saying kiddush in shul on Friday nights.
2. in the Diaspora it was often dangerous for Jews to light the menora outside their homes properly, this was a way to have a public lighting that would accomplish the publicizing of the miracle
3. as a commemoration of the lighting in the beis hamikdash
4. a bracha is made on the lighting in shul even though it is only a minhag, just as a bracha is said when reciting Hallel on Rosh Chodesh, which is also a minhag
This has become the common custom, to make the rbacha on the lighting in shul, even though it is just a minhag and there is some halachic opposition to it, and even Sefardim make a bracha on the lighting in shul even though they don't make a bracha on Rosh Chodesh Hallel.

A common question is if one should light the menora at any public event, such as Chanukah parties, weddings during Chanukah, and the like, similarly to the way we light in shul, as another opportunity to publicize the miracle. Many poskim have said to not make a bracha at such lights, but some poskim have said that one should make the bracha when the party is taking place outdoors, especially if the people who already lit did so indoors in their houses rather than outdoors.

So the question is if davening in a minyan outdoors is like davening in a shul with the minhag being to light with a bracha or maybe it is like any public gathering in which most poskim hold no bracha is made?

It seems such a minyan could be compared to a shul and they would light with a bracha. Even regarding parties some rabbonim have paskened that if there will be davening at the event it would be considered like a shul and they could light with a bracha.  

In the case of the original question regarding the street minyanim, because the minyanim have already been in place for a long time, it should be considered like a shul, and they could light the menora at the street minyan with a bracha. 
source: Ynet



Posted by Rafi G. at 4:24 PM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Labels: CoronaVirus, Hanukah, interesting psak

1 comment:

  1. joel richDecember 09, 2020 4:51 PM

    https://www.yutorah.org/lectures/lecture.cfm/980098/rabbi-hershel-schachter/piskei-corona-57-lighting-chanuka-candles-in-shul/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
      Reply
Add comment
Load more...

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Pages

  • Home
  • Advertise on Life in Israel!





Design Your Own




Disclaimer: Some of the links and banners on Life in Israel are ads, and some are affiliate links. Affiliate links are links that will earn me a commission off any purchases you might make after clicking on the link/banner, though you will not pay more because of that.

Search This Blog

About Me

Rafi G.
OpaDeMaya
View my complete profile

My Other Blogs

  • Rabbi Running a Marathon
    ok 6
    7 months ago

Jewish/Israel Content Sites

  • Cholim List
  • Israel's Water Level - Daily Update

Blog Archive

  • ►  2025 (621)
    • ►  December (12)
    • ►  November (40)
    • ►  October (32)
    • ►  September (36)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (63)
    • ►  June (56)
    • ►  May (62)
    • ►  April (44)
    • ►  March (54)
    • ►  February (77)
    • ►  January (104)
  • ►  2024 (1243)
    • ►  December (104)
    • ►  November (93)
    • ►  October (103)
    • ►  September (95)
    • ►  August (105)
    • ►  July (101)
    • ►  June (93)
    • ►  May (95)
    • ►  April (107)
    • ►  March (121)
    • ►  February (91)
    • ►  January (135)
  • ►  2023 (1475)
    • ►  December (148)
    • ►  November (152)
    • ►  October (151)
    • ►  September (89)
    • ►  August (97)
    • ►  July (115)
    • ►  June (112)
    • ►  May (112)
    • ►  April (96)
    • ►  March (147)
    • ►  February (119)
    • ►  January (137)
  • ►  2022 (1581)
    • ►  December (138)
    • ►  November (145)
    • ►  October (102)
    • ►  September (126)
    • ►  August (149)
    • ►  July (118)
    • ►  June (126)
    • ►  May (124)
    • ►  April (107)
    • ►  March (147)
    • ►  February (153)
    • ►  January (146)
  • ►  2021 (1681)
    • ►  December (141)
    • ►  November (152)
    • ►  October (142)
    • ►  September (82)
    • ►  August (135)
    • ►  July (110)
    • ►  June (91)
    • ►  May (171)
    • ►  April (143)
    • ►  March (154)
    • ►  February (176)
    • ►  January (184)
  • ▼  2020 (2161)
    • ▼  December (202)
      • Quote of the Day
      • Fractious elections ahead of us
      • Interesting Psak: accepting charity from United Ar...
      • Tweet of the Day
      • Pollard and Politics
      • Quote of the Day
      • Picture of the Day
      • PM Netanyahu greets Jonathan and Esther Pollard up...
      • Shuli Rand & Motty Steinmetz Tzama (video)
      • Quote of the Day
      • screaming does pay
      • Netanyahu gets what he wants, though it is too lat...
      • Another mockdown
      • timely Corona tests still difficult to obtain
      • Drive-Thru voting
      • Kindness Survives 2020! (how those in need still s...
      • BAR STOOL FUND (KEN'S DINER) FILM (video)
      • What do Israelis wish for in the New Year? (video)
      • UnderDos: My brother is getting vaccinated (video)
      • KEL MALEH - Echoes from our Past - Benzion Klatzko...
      • Quote of the Day
      • Saar announces electoral reform platform
      • Rabbis Schachter and WIllig apologize for getting ...
      • Son of Holocaust Survivor - How He's Become Succes...
      • Palestinians: If a Palestinian refugee receives fo...
      • Behind the Bima S2E13, Special Guest: Meir Kay (vi...
      • The Magic Yarmulkah - Pitch Meeting (video)
      • Shulem - Rise Up (Cover) (video)
      • 3rd lockdown like the 1st or 2nd
      • Fighting in UTJ to give the other the top position
      • getting the COVID-19 vaccine in NY
      • Quote of the Day
      • Headlines Podcast: 12/26/20 – Show 303 – Secular H...
      • MK Naftali Bennett on Ofira and Berkovitch: these ...
      • UnderDos: The Chanukiyah of Yehudadi (video)
      • Synagogues of New York Part 85 West Hempstead (video)
      • Nemouel - Chalom (Official Music Video)
      • Shvurei Lev cover by Shai Abramson for 10 Teves (v...
      • the way to vaccinate everyone easily
      • Chinese food on Christmas
      • Quote of the Day
      • can Shelach attract voters from the Right?
      • Interesting Psak: CoronaVirus vaccinations on Shabbos
      • Kushner, Netanyahu Israeli delegation, Morocco, et...
      • MK Bennett announces candidacy for PM of Israel (v...
      • Ashley Blaker on Christmas (video)
      • Exclusive Interview With Former Iranian National J...
      • Sruli Broncher ft. Dovid Pearlman // Let Go (Offic...
      • Tweet of the Day
      • Interesting Psak: goverment as a beis din
      • picture of the Chafetz Chaim discovered
      • Interesting Psak: change text of Avinu Malkeinu
      • Quote of the Day
      • the never-ending speech by MK Yitzchak Pindrus in ...
      • Camp Mesivta Circa 1942 (video)
      • Exclusive Interview With Muslim Emirati Delegation...
      • Space IL Co-Founder: 'Israel is Returning to the M...
      • Refaeinu - Klatzko Family - Composed by Benzion Kl...
      • this year's Thanksgivukah
      • Overdose on CoronaVirus vaccine
      • Quote of the Day
      • Picture of the Day
      • why we all use the same tune when lighting Chanuka...
      • Jeremy Saltan Debate vs Mitchell Barak on Gidon Sa...
      • The HatzalaCast Episode 4 | Dr. Zecie Maltz | The ...
      • Lenny Solomon Live (video)
      • MI K'AMCHA YISROEL - Joey Newcomb feat. Benny Frie...
      • Quote of the Day
      • not high risk
      • Picture of the Day
      • Shtissel, S03E01 - Season Premiere! (video)
      • Lifestyle Of A Hasidic Woman (video)
      • Israelis: Did you know that Jews were safer under ...
      • Behind the Bima S2E12 - Special Guest: Lori Palatn...
      • Avraham Fried and Aviv Gefen: Batzoret (audio)
      • Shalva Band: Moment to Shine (video)
      • a little bit of good will can go a long way
      • Bad timing?
      • Peace/Normalization with UAE, Dayeinu
      • 12/19/20 – Show 302 – Should we take the Covid Vac...
      • PM Netanyahu and Minister Edelstein get first Coro...
      • IDF Ultimate Mystery Donut Challenge (video)
      • Bardak: what will they say? (video)
      • Chaya Kogan- The Gift- Волшебный Подарок- For Wome...
      • Quote of the Day
      • Tweet of the Day
      • Happy Hanukkah from Kamala Harris and Doug Emhoff ...
      • What Hasidic Women Have To Say (eye-opening experi...
      • Whiskey from the land of milk and honey (video)
      • Jay Leno shares his support and love for Israel (v...
      • Kippalive & Beit Issie Shapiro | Be A Light (video)
      • Tov Lehodot by Franciska ft. Maayan Davis *Kolisha...
      • sending Malka Leifer home
      • I See the Light - Tangled (Live) | Shulem ft. The ...
      • Gad Elbaz feat. Saul Dreier & Dor V'dor - Hanukkah...
      • Evanston Symphony Orchestra Wendel A Chanukah Over...
      • Burning Bright | by Bracha Jaffe & Shaindy Plotzke...
      • Bet Shemesh celebrates 70 years! (video)
      • Palestinians: Do you understand Israel's need for ...
      • ARAB MUSLIM & HASIDIC JEW GO SHOPPING AT DUBAI MAL...
    • ►  November (125)
    • ►  October (183)
    • ►  September (204)
    • ►  August (157)
    • ►  July (186)
    • ►  June (202)
    • ►  May (178)
    • ►  April (164)
    • ►  March (196)
    • ►  February (191)
    • ►  January (173)
  • ►  2019 (1919)
    • ►  December (185)
    • ►  November (130)
    • ►  October (114)
    • ►  September (153)
    • ►  August (139)
    • ►  July (192)
    • ►  June (167)
    • ►  May (157)
    • ►  April (165)
    • ►  March (176)
    • ►  February (164)
    • ►  January (177)
  • ►  2018 (1780)
    • ►  December (161)
    • ►  November (167)
    • ►  October (154)
    • ►  September (80)
    • ►  August (110)
    • ►  July (146)
    • ►  June (164)
    • ►  May (158)
    • ►  April (124)
    • ►  March (169)
    • ►  February (156)
    • ►  January (191)
  • ►  2017 (1809)
    • ►  December (166)
    • ►  November (172)
    • ►  October (127)
    • ►  September (157)
    • ►  August (157)
    • ►  July (169)
    • ►  June (170)
    • ►  May (143)
    • ►  April (110)
    • ►  March (126)
    • ►  February (136)
    • ►  January (176)
  • ►  2016 (1810)
    • ►  December (167)
    • ►  November (171)
    • ►  October (70)
    • ►  September (146)
    • ►  August (119)
    • ►  July (156)
    • ►  June (177)
    • ►  May (174)
    • ►  April (133)
    • ►  March (171)
    • ►  February (168)
    • ►  January (158)
  • ►  2015 (1919)
    • ►  December (167)
    • ►  November (165)
    • ►  October (151)
    • ►  September (115)
    • ►  August (169)
    • ►  July (167)
    • ►  June (169)
    • ►  May (148)
    • ►  April (129)
    • ►  March (184)
    • ►  February (173)
    • ►  January (182)
  • ►  2014 (2184)
    • ►  December (201)
    • ►  November (169)
    • ►  October (138)
    • ►  September (179)
    • ►  August (199)
    • ►  July (231)
    • ►  June (209)
    • ►  May (172)
    • ►  April (138)
    • ►  March (160)
    • ►  February (184)
    • ►  January (204)
  • ►  2013 (2182)
    • ►  December (206)
    • ►  November (146)
    • ►  October (190)
    • ►  September (126)
    • ►  August (174)
    • ►  July (185)
    • ►  June (185)
    • ►  May (197)
    • ►  April (203)
    • ►  March (174)
    • ►  February (185)
    • ►  January (211)
  • ►  2012 (2117)
    • ►  December (194)
    • ►  November (177)
    • ►  October (142)
    • ►  September (156)
    • ►  August (169)
    • ►  July (192)
    • ►  June (175)
    • ►  May (185)
    • ►  April (160)
    • ►  March (178)
    • ►  February (190)
    • ►  January (199)
  • ►  2011 (1914)
    • ►  December (177)
    • ►  November (178)
    • ►  October (148)
    • ►  September (199)
    • ►  August (173)
    • ►  July (164)
    • ►  June (153)
    • ►  May (135)
    • ►  April (118)
    • ►  March (171)
    • ►  February (141)
    • ►  January (157)
  • ►  2010 (1564)
    • ►  December (163)
    • ►  November (133)
    • ►  October (134)
    • ►  September (108)
    • ►  August (140)
    • ►  July (144)
    • ►  June (161)
    • ►  May (115)
    • ►  April (105)
    • ►  March (117)
    • ►  February (112)
    • ►  January (132)
  • ►  2009 (1158)
    • ►  December (124)
    • ►  November (102)
    • ►  October (93)
    • ►  September (116)
    • ►  August (74)
    • ►  July (108)
    • ►  June (97)
    • ►  May (74)
    • ►  April (68)
    • ►  March (85)
    • ►  February (86)
    • ►  January (131)
  • ►  2008 (973)
    • ►  December (88)
    • ►  November (91)
    • ►  October (42)
    • ►  September (83)
    • ►  August (76)
    • ►  July (91)
    • ►  June (85)
    • ►  May (107)
    • ►  April (86)
    • ►  March (86)
    • ►  February (74)
    • ►  January (64)
  • ►  2007 (687)
    • ►  December (65)
    • ►  November (54)
    • ►  October (51)
    • ►  September (51)
    • ►  August (44)
    • ►  July (53)
    • ►  June (73)
    • ►  May (62)
    • ►  April (51)
    • ►  March (67)
    • ►  February (58)
    • ►  January (58)
  • ►  2006 (470)
    • ►  December (44)
    • ►  November (40)
    • ►  October (36)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (46)
    • ►  July (47)
    • ►  June (23)
    • ►  May (27)
    • ►  April (20)
    • ►  March (47)
    • ►  February (38)
    • ►  January (81)
  • ►  2005 (7)
    • ►  December (7)
Life in Israel, Rafi G.. Ethereal theme. Powered by Blogger.