Featured Post
Free The Hostages! Bring Them Home!
(this is a featured post and will stay at the top for the foreseeable future.. scroll down for new posts) -------------------------------...
Sep 10, 2015
It is ok to break the law for soccer
The Israeli football (soccer) leagues playing on Shabbos continues.
Recently a labor court judge ruled that it is illegal for them to be playing on Shabbos (as part of the league). The case was brought before the court by religious athletes.
Since then the news and media have been debating non-stop whether the leagues should or will, or not, be given a special allowance by the Minister of Commerce to play on Shabbos. The league has also threatened to stop functioning altogether if it isnt given the special allowance.
One of the problems with this is that the Minister of Commerce is Aryeh Deri, a frum Jew who is not going to be so quick to sign on an allowance for desecration of Shabbos, especially when pikuach nefesh is not involved.
According to Ladaat, Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein has issued an order to allow the league to continue playing on Shabbos, despite the illegality of it. Weisntein explained that because the law has not been enforced until now, since the inception of the State, there is no reason to begin enforcing it now.
I'm not a lawyer, but I do not like the sounds of someone like the Attorney General saying a law does not need to be enforced just because it has not been until now.
Are the law books filled with laws that we can selectively choose which we want to keep and which we do not?
Besides for Weinstein, I would like to know if anyone knows why historically the league never asked for an allowance? Many operations have - I saw a list that included Bezeq, the Electric Company, and many others. Why did the league never ask for it?
------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------
Labels:
chillul shabbos,
sports
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
"especially when pikuach nefesh is not involved."
ReplyDeleteBut pikuach nefesh *IS* involved ... if he stops the soccer games, the fans will kill him! :-)
You may remember that yeshiva students once had a deferral [dichui] from the army [not a patur]. This was granted by the defense minister from way back when. Then in the 2000s the esteemed enlightened bagatz decided that that was not legal. And it made no difference that it was done for over 50 years. The hypocrisy in this country is amazing. Where are all those that cry out chok hashilton? i think the attorney general needs to be investigated for proposing and inciting the breaking of the law. Rafi, maybe you can get a petition started for this purpose.
ReplyDelete