Nov 22, 2026

Interesting Psak: same person, different appearance

Rav Yitzchak Zilberstein, rav of Ramat Elconon neighborhood of Bnei Braq, discussed in his shiur a question he was recently asked regarding a shidduch.

The question posed asked about a shadchan who "redt", proposed, a shidduch to the father of a wonderful girl, as they were looking for a young man with similar excellent qualities and traits. The shadchan proposed a young man who met all their "requirements" or whatever you might call what they are looking for. He was smart, learned, dedicated to his learning, good charchter traits, gentle and God-fearing. They accepted the proposal and set a date.

The young lady was excited to meet the young man with such qualities and reputation and she arrived at the meeting point waiting to meet him. When he appeared she suddenly and immediately went from excitement to disappointment and shame and nearly fainted from the shock. 

The young man who walked in might have been a wonderful young man but he was also obese and she could not see herself together with him. the shadchan, and nobody else they had checked with, had said anything about him being on the larger side, let alone obese. It is not what she imagined, and she could not see herself walking beside him with everyone looking and commenting and wondering what was wrong with her that she ended up with someone like that, despite the fact that he has wonderful charchter traits.

After her initial shock she composed herself and controlled herself and the date went on as planned, so as not hurt his feelings. She did see in him the wonderful traits she had heard about; God-fearing, smart, learned, etc, but the obesity was not something she could overlook.

After going home she told the shadchan that the shidduch is not relevant due to his carrying too much extra weight and she could not see herself marrying someone like that and what people would say when seeing them together, and they broke it off.

About a year later, while the father of the young maiden was at a wedding, a young man approached him. After confirming who they each are, he explained that in the past year he had changed his eating habits and had lost a lot of weight and also had bariatric surgery, and as could be seen very well now, he was a thin and handomse young man, still with all those great qualities that she had like back then a year prior.

The father proposed to the young man that they go out on a date. One thing led to another, they each liked each other and decided to marry, he proposed, and mazel tov a wedding was to be scheduled.

The shadchan form a year prior heard about the two getting engaged and stepped forward claiming that he should be paid (by each side) for the shidduch he had proposed a year earlier, that indeed worked out toward a marriage despite it taking some extar time.

Both sides argued that when the shidduch had been proposed, it did not work out. The young man is a new, different person, after doing what he needed to do to change... "you had recommended an obese young man that did not work out, and this young man is someone else, a thin and handsome young man with tremendous qualities but this is not who you recommended."

So the question posed to Rav Zilbershtein was asking if they need to pay the shadchan who had recommended this young man  a year prior or if this is something new with a new different young man, essentially a different shidduch, and maybe the parents owe the shadchan nothing?

Rav Zilbershtein answered that people do not get married with external appearanced, but with internal personalities, with a nefesh. When he was fat she was not going to be marrying his fat. The mnarriage is between the people, bot between fat or skinny or some other part of the appearance.

The shadchan proposed a wonderful shidduch between two wonderful people and they liked each other, and that's the main part of the shidduch. His being obese is a minor side point, not the main part of the shidduch. Removing the fat is not making a new person, like someone who cut off a wart, it does not make a new person, it is the same person who got rid of a minor defect.

After some further discussion Rav Zilbershtein paskened that the main thing is his yiras shamayim and good charachter traits. The rest is externals and not important. The shadchan is entitled to his fee as the shidduch he proposed had been successful (even if it took longer than originally expected) and the extreme weight loss does not turn him into a new person.
sources: Kikar, Babli


The only thing I would add is that the shadchan (and anyone else involved who decided to not mention it) should also be reproved for not mentioning the obesity. it is not like she would not notice. The shdachan should not be deceiving people to get dates.




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Halacha Headlines: 11/21/26 – Shiur 584 – Why can’t we concentrate anymore? ADHD, technology or lack of motivation? (audio)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

TZFAT: The Ancient Blue Mystical City (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jerusalem City today. From Central Station to the city center. (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

All Week Shabbos - Yaakov Shwekey (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Chasof חשוף | Mendy Portnoy מנדי פורטנוי | CHANUKA (A Live Piano Album) (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Nov 17, 2026

What If Making Aliyah To Israel Is Easier Than You've Been Told. (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

🇮🇱 Inside Bnei Brak – A Different Side of Israel | 4K HDR Walking Tour (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Shimmy Lipshitz & Motty Vizel - Chonenu (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Nov 16, 2026

Why Rabbi Shalom Rosner Left America at the Peak of His Career- BEHIND THE BIMA (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Lior Raz Delivers a Powerful Message to Jews Worldwide: Never Be Afraid to Be Jewish! (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Tel Aviv Urban Walk 4K | Colorful City Journey (video)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

The Becher Brothers, in memory of their brother Yehuda killed at Nova: Nishar Hagaagua (video)






to remind you, a week before he was killed, Yehuda Becher recorded himself singing Alokai Neshama


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Nov 15, 2026

Toyota investigating misuse of its equipment

According to reports, Toyota is investigating claims that Israel used Toyota-manufactured forklifts improperly during the war in some form of military use. Middle East Eye published photos of Toyota forklifts being used in Israeli military munitions warehouses and in other logistical capacities, and they say it may violate the terms of use.





1. is the big investigation here to determine if they should cancel the warranty?

2. Did Toyota ever "investigate" how Hamas used their pickup trucks on October 7 2023? Are they investigating the fair use of those pickup trucks?









------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Picture of the Day



that is MK Elisha Medan (Likud) who set up a tent outside the Knesset and said he will stay there (with his two boys) until a unity government is etsablished

Personally I think a unity government is the only viable option, beside for it being what I think the country needs in order to heel. Obviously Bibi will have to give Eisenkott real gaurantees that he wont screw him like the way he screwed all other unity partners, most recently Benny Gantz, but if that can be managed and they can sit and negotiate a realistic arrangement together, that is really the best and only viable option right now.




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Halacha Headlines: 11/14/26 – Shiur 583 – Why men and women don't understand each other – and how it affects Shalom Bayis (audio)








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...