Showing posts with label Yamina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yamina. Show all posts

Apr 6, 2022

Coalition teetering as Silman resigns

It seems the only thing happening today is Idit Silman announcing her resignation from the coalition, throwing the entire political situation into a tizzy. Will it lead to a new government in the current coalition? Will it lead to new elections? Will it calm down and will she reverse her decision? Will the Opposition find another defector? Will Yair Lapid be the Prime Minister over a caretaker government or will Bennett remain PM until elections (these two options depend on how the government falls, if it will) or neither? 

So many questions and so many possible scenarios.

Whatever happens remains to be seen, all we can do is wait. I am not in the business of predictions or prophecy. In the meantime, we can just comment on what happened. 

The government overall functioned ok but it definitely had a dysfunctional aspect to it. They both had difficulty passing the main laws and reforms it had set as goals for itself and sold to the public, while at the same time the individual parties within the coalition were proposing laws that were upsetting other parts of the coalition. Instead of recognizing that the coalition is fragile and care must be taken to not disillusion other members too much, they each tried to take as advantage of the situation as possible, perhaps recognizing that this might be their only chance and the chance and opportunity might be short lived. Sometimes parties played along and supported even though they were upset and sometimes they did not, only to cause the other parties to be upset. Governments and coalitions cannot function like this, especially with just a razor thin majority. They were not wise enough or bold enough to work for the people, but were each seen as working for themselves and at most their own narrow sectors, taking and handing out  too many jobs, creating too many ministerial positions and deputy and other jobs...

It is hard to believe that of all the issues that have played out over the past year or so, it is the Supreme Court decision on bread that Nitzan Horowitz instructed hospitals to adhere to that forced Silman's hand. Any other government will have to deal with the same Supreme Court decision, and she did not bear responsibility for it, so I am not sure what was really the impetus for this resignation. Was it the job Netanyahu promised her? Was it just the straw that broke the camels back? Was it the pressure form the Opposition? Was it a bad relationship with Bennett or other members of Yamina?  Silman herself seemed unstable for the past year (I am not familiar with her style enough to know if it went longer than that) and seemed to waffle back and forth on different issues regularly, and came under attack regularly from the Opposition seeing her as a weak link and a good target. her claim of having been attacked drew particularly harsh attention from the Opposition and they made her into a laughing stock over that. I dont know, and I dont know if we will ever really know, what and why this is all about.


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 5, 2021

Will Netanyahu's Mandate Expire? (May 3 2021) (video)









------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 3, 2021

Jeremy Saltan on End of 1st Mandate (April 28 2021) (video)











------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jan 4, 2021

Yamina and Saar agreement leaves Likud hanging

The news is reporting that the two political parties, Yamina (lef by Naftali bennett) and Tikva Chadasha (led by Gideon Saar) have just signed an agreement for sharing each party's excess votes with the other in the upcoming elections.

Besides for this being done very early, it is a major move. In the past four or five elections and Knessets, the Likud has signed this agreement with Yamina (in its various forms). Yamina signing now with Gideon Saar is a big move. 

Not only that, it also leaves Likud without any natural partner party to sign with. 

Likud could sign with Yisrael Beyteynu, as has been done a bit further back in election history, but Avigdor Lieberman and Bibi Netanyahu are not on such good terms nowadays, and neither are their parties.

Likud could theoretically sign with Zelikha's party, but polls so far don't have them getting into the Knesset, and they are more likely to merge with another party. I cannot see the Likud risk throwing out votes like that in what might be another close election in which every vote counts.

They could sign with Shas, as they are natural partners as well, but Shas always signs the agreement with UTJ, and I don't see that changing. It could if Netanyahu gets really desperate and Shas decides to save him, but it is not likely. 

The only other party that seems to be available to sign with Likud might be the party of Mansour Abbas, if he breaks Raam off from the rest of the joint Arab List. Netanyahu has been cozying up to Abbas recently and while it seems like a ridiculous idea, I can see it happening.




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 21, 2020

it is a two-way street

Yamina sent/went into the Opposition has brought about something interesting very quickly.

The job of parties in the Opposition is, on the one hand to protect its constituents interests from the government that might trample on the rights of others, and on the other hand to work to bring down the coalition.

Yamina complained that the Haredi parties did not fight for Yamina to be int he coalition and only made some statements as lip service. Bennett felt, or at least said, that the Haredi parties should have refused to enter the coalition without Yamina.

Today it is being reported that Yamina shockingly now has an agreement and working arrangement with Yisrael Beyteynu in the Opposition. Yamina is, for now, denying it saying Yisrael Beyteynu has become an anti-Jewish party that sent Israel to 3 rounds of elections and Yamina isnt working with them. Some might, or do, say that Bennett is somewhat at fault for the election rounds because of his original split and not passing the minimum threshold - so his accusation on YB rings hollow, and his response rings hollow.

MK Moshe Gafni spoke up today, in response to the initial accusation by Bennett that the Haredi parties did nothing to ensure Yamina's place in the coalition. Gafni said, "Yamina cannot come to us with complaints - what did they expect, that we will negotiate for them so they can get jobs, some of them being ones we wanted for us? Such a thing does not exist even between Shas and UTJ!"

Gafni is right. I said that myself (link above). That is not how it works. UTJ does not need to fight for Yamina, and without a formal agreement to stick together, each party only looks out for its own narrow interests. UTj doesnt need Yamina, when it can get whatever it wants from Netanyahu, so it has no need to fight for Yamina - definitely not without an actual agreement to do so.

But it works both ways. It is a two-way street.

Now that Yamina is in the Opposition, UTJ, Gafni, Netanyahu, Shas and all the other coalition members should not get upset when Yamina works against their interests. What does UTJ expect - that Yamina should not work together with Yisrael Beyteynu and Yesh Atid to bring down the government and to make trouble for the coalition? UTJ thinks Bennett should do things in the most inefficient way, fighting alone, so that UTJ's interests will be protected from Lieberman? UTJ let Yamina be pushed out but doesnt want Yamina to do anything effective against them? That is also not how it works. If they do not make a working arrangement with Lieberman to work to bring down the government I would be even more disappointed in Yamina. That is what their job calls for right now. They are not there to protect UTJ or Shas or Kachol Lavan or Likud or anyone in particular. They need to protect the interests of the Dati Leumi community, work to bring down the Coalition or to change it and to get themselves in to the government where they can have influence.Every party in the Opposition has that role.



------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 14, 2020

Coalition Building

1. With Rav Rafi Peretz splitting off from Yamina, Netanyahu's brilliance in political maneuvering comes through once again. Not because he got Peretz - that is not so important for anything besides Netanyahu's image and support in the right wing. Peretz is taking a job that is almost meaningless, so the job and connection is meaningless for everything except image. Netanyahu's brilliance is in being able to hold the Likud together, even while making almost every Likud politician unhappy, while ravaging [almost] every other party.

Netanyahu has now successfully dismantled Kachol Lavan, Yamina, Labor and the Labor-Gesher-Meretz bloc.

Netanyahu's leadership skills and political savvy will be, or should be, studied for generations.

2. With Rav Rafi Peretz splitting off from Yamina and Joining the Netanyahu-led coalition he has shown, again or further, how fragmented the Dati Leumi community leadership is. Peretz is well respected (though not necessarily as a politician), yet he broke a major promise to Ben Gvir for "the sake of unity" in the DL camp, and now he is breaking up that unity for a minor ministry in a bloated government. It is not even for anything important or significant.

Perhaps Bennett deserved such turnabout, as he himself did similarly in previous election cycles, but at least Bennett did it for fairly important and significant roles and influence. Peretz is doing it for a meaningless ministry with almost no authority created just for him to join the coalition. Anyone who criticizes Bennett for his past breakaways and splits but praises and supports Peretz is being hypocritical and vindictive. And Peretz is not just screwing Bennett and Shaked, but also Smotritch and his supporters.

I am amazed Mafdal/BayitYehudi/Yamina still has any voters and supporters at all. They have shown themselves time and again to be selfish politicians (as perhaps many are) with almost no influence.








------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 13, 2020

no brit achim between Yamina and Haredi parties

 The news is reporting that senior officials in the Yamina party are upset, or perhaps disappointed is a better word, with the Haredi parties. They say that Gafni, Litzman and Deri should have all refused to join the coalition unless the entire bloc was taken in, meaning Yamina.

They are implying some unspoken understanding and are upset that the heads of the Haredi parties haven't lived up to it but are looking out for their own interests.

Sorry, Yamina, but that is not how it works. If the two parties made an official agreement, than it would be fair to demand upholding the agreement to only go in together. Yamina's commitment all along was to support Netanyahu, not to support UTJ or Shas. Yamina has a problem with Netanyahu, but that is not the fault of UTJ and Shas.

UTJ has its own problems now with Netanyahu, as some last minute requests to add clauses to the coalition agreement about religion and State issues are not being accepted (as of now), but I suspect that will work itself out one way or another and will not prevent UTJ and/or Shas from joining the coalition.  They have their own issues to deal with that for them take preference over helping Yamina, even if they wanted to (which they claim to be trying) - but with no commitment to a "brit achim" like Bennett had with Lapid in 2013, there is no reason for them to put their necks on the line for Yamina
 


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...