Featured Post
Free The Hostages! Bring Them Home!
(this is a featured post and will stay at the top for the foreseeable future.. scroll down for new posts) -------------------------------...
Feb 3, 2022
opposed to cholent
This feels disrespectful., though I dont mean it to be.
I find this funny - funny that this is a big issue important enough for an important rabbi's attention.
A class of 8th grade students went to pay a visit to Rav Shimon Baadani, to talk with him and get his blesing.
During their meeting, Rav Baadani commented on the phenomenon of yeshiva bochurim going out to eat cholent on Thursday nights. Rav Baadani thinks this is a bad thing and it pains him to hear about this. Rav Baadani explained that this time should be used to learn Torah. Thursday nights was always dedicated to learning Torah, reviewing and learning late into the night. Back int he day Rav Shach woud make sure the talmidim had what to eat Thursday nights late while learning, in addition to making sure there was milk for the coffee so they would learn better - but to eat cholent late into the night and burn the night away is painful.
source: Actualic
He might be technically right. Doing anything at any time other than learning Torah is bittul torah.
But.
But, kids need an outlet or to get a break every now and then. Eating cholent is better than sitting around and smoking weed and getting drunk or doing drugs. Waste of time? maybe but kids need to waste some time sometimes. Eating cholent doesnt need to be an all night event - maybe encourage them to spend an hour or two out with the guys eating cholent and shmoozing and then getting back to the beis medrash for a night of learning. Maybe encourage the yeshiva to serve cholent Thursday nights so the boys wont have to go elsewhere but can take a break, which will almost definitely naturally be shorter, in the yeshiva and shmooze a bit and then get back to learning.
And some would say OK, Boomer to this. Back in the day we spent Thursday nights drinking coffee and were extra happy if we got milk, and these kids today need cholent????
Aren't there worse things to oppose than cholent?
------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------
Labels:
cholent,
yesha bachurim
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You are missing the forest for the trees. The issue is not cholent, but making a whole night out, rather than learning. He could say the same thing if bochurim started to go out for sushi on Thursday nights.
ReplyDeleteIt's all about trade-offs imho. How many will be saved from burnout vs. how many could've been gedolim if they used that time for learning?
ReplyDeleteKT