Featured Post

Free The Hostages! Bring Them Home!

(this is a featured post and will stay at the top for the foreseeable future.. scroll down for new posts) -------------------------------...

Nov 29, 2023

who controls the narrative?

One of the things done differently, in my perception, with this war on Hamas/Gaza than what was done in other wars/operations and day to day dealings is that Israel was proactive. Yes, Israel went to war as a reaction to the Hamas massacre, but since then Israel has been proactive in destroying Gaza and Hamas and seeking out the tunnels and the terrorists and doing what it determines is needed to do to defeat Hamas/Gaza. Israel quickly took control of the situation and for the most part managed it well (not including PR and the expanding antisemitism around the world with global support largely for Hamas).

Ever since the hostage situation took center stage with the ceasefire and negotiations, it seems to me that Israel gave up the stronger proactive hand and has been playing catch up. Israel has been reacting to Hamas. Israel has been managed by Hamas (and perhaps other powers). Hamas has been mainly managing the narrative and managing the situation. What Hamas demands, Israel does.

I get it. Israel wants the hostages back, so we do what we must. It is one of the main objectives of the war. It is one of the most important things on the table for Israelis.

Because it, because we are letting Hamas control the situation, the tables have turned. We havent and arent losing the war, but the tides are turning - the ceasefire is likely to be extended, every time Hamas plays a game we just take it, once the ceasefire is going for 6,7, 8, 10, 12 days, the world wont be so quick to give Israel a long leash again for restarting the war at the same scale it was at before. We are reacting to everything Hamas demands and to the games Hamas plays.

Israel needs to take back control of the narrative. Yes, we want the hostages back, but Hamas also wants things from us. They want Palestinian prisoners released. They want quiet in gaza with some time to breath and regroup. They want us to not fly over northern Gaza for parts of the day so they can "look for more hostages".... they want things from us, so we can play games with them, we can make demands. Israel needs to stop responding to Hamas and must take control of the narrative. make our demands. Say no extension, go back to blowing things up and killing terrorists and make an offer that Hamas will have to respond to. Make the offers, dont accept the offers, and blow them up until they do. 

it is all about who controls the narrative, and right now Hamas does. Israel has to take that back.


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

4 comments:

  1. Once lost, hard to regain.
    Israel's narrative should have remained rock solid - the minute Hamas surrenders and returns all the hostages - ALL OF THEM - we'll agree to a ceasefire. Until then don't bother calling us.
    Now Israel has blinked and our enemies have us. Biden knows he can pretend to be supportive while pandering to the Woke vote by pushing for Israel to slowly give up in Gaza. A way to ensure Hamas survives will be found in the name of "peace". The ceasefire will drag out until it becomes the new normal. Not good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The well-financed harpies shrieking "Deal Now!" combined with a scared-of-the-media Bibi and indebted-to-the-Left Gantz and Gallant didn't help.

      Delete
    2. I disagree. I have no problem with a ceasefire and hostage exchange, but Israel should be dictating terms, Israel should not be reacting to Hamas demands. And when there are violations, Israel should make them pay.

      Delete
    3. Israel probably couldn't move forward without US ammo. Bibi failed to live up to Begin standing up to Biden. Yes, to show we meant business, Israel should have used the smallest infraction by Hamas to resume the offensive.

      Delete

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...