Showing posts with label Israeli Arabs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Israeli Arabs. Show all posts

Aug 18, 2024

send draft notices

Minister Dudi Amsalem stepped up to the building of the Supreme Court to petition it, once again (or as he says, for the fifth time) to draft the Arab citizens of Israel - they should either serve in the IDF or at least perform National Service, like any other Israeli.



I happen to agree with him that Arab citizens of Israel should either serve in the IDF or perform National Service (one or the other, as the compulsory service law requires).

But what does that have to do with the Supreme Court? It isnt the Supreme Court that says Arabs dont have to serve. It is the government (historically, all of them, not just this one) and the IDF that has chosen to not send draft notices to the Arab community, for whatever reason (the reason is not important for this discussion- they dont send draft notices is all that is important at the moment). Amsalem is trying to point to some sort of hypocrisy in how it is treating Haredim while it is not doing the same for the Arabs. He might be right but that hypocrisy is the fault of the government, not the Supreme Court.

What does that have to do with the Supreme Court? Dudi Amsalem is part of the current government. What he needs to do is raise the issue in the next government meeting and start a discussion. Persuade the rest of the government that we should draft the Arab citizens (and they can do either IDF service or National Service), order the IDF to send draft notices. Once that happens, the Arab citizens can either fight it and be subject to losing budgets and subsidies, or their people can start serving. This has nothing to do with the Supreme Court. The government just needs to decide to start sending draft notices.



------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Mar 31, 2024

Dudi Amsalem

Minister Dudi Amsalem just filed a petition with the Supreme Court to draft the Arab community in Israel to the IDF.

Amsalem thinks he is standing up for and helping his coalition partners, the Haredi community, by filing this petition, as if he is pointing out a massive hypocrisy. Amsalem says the Israeli Arab community gets benefits just like everyone else in Israel but does not share in the burden of army service. And like the Supreme Court just ordered the Haredi community to be drafted for lack of a law exempting them, the Arab community should be drafted as well. The Arab community does not get automatic exemptions, but the IDF does not send them draft notices.

I am not sure who Amsalem thinks he is hurting or helping. He is a member of the government, and has been for a long time. If the Arabs are not drafted it is because his governments chose not to (for security reasons). So now he wants to force his government to draft them? he could probably have just gone to PM Netanyahu and said if this is what they are doing to the Haredim let's also draft the Arabs. He didnt have to go to the Supreme Court. They are not being drafted not because they refuse to be drafted and go to the army for religious reasons but because the Israeli government chooses to not draft them because the Israeli government thinks as a whole they cant be trusted regarding security, dual loyalties perhaps or whatnot.

And if they are not being drafted for security reasons, Amsalem thinks getting back at the Supreme Court is more important than the security of Israel? He's thinking I am going to show them how hypocritical they are and I am going to put us all at risk in doing so!?

If the government thinks they have ways to draft the Arabs and they can do it without being a security risk, I am all for it. I think the Arabs should be required to do at least National Service if they dont go to the army. I think most Haredim should do at least National Service as well. Again, Amsalem is part of the government - he does not need to go to fight in the Supreme Court to do this, just pass a law. The only reason the Supreme Court got involved is because for years Netanyahu and his various governments have refused, or failed, to pass a law for the draft to make a legal arrangement with the Haredi community. This government is all about personal benefits and games instead of doing the real work.  




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Mar 25, 2024

Do Arab-Israelis Stand with Israel? | Ami on the Loose (video)







------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Apr 11, 2022

Udah not so conciliatory after all

The Israeli public, or maybe it is actually the media, is fickle. 

MK Ayman Udah (United Arab List) said yesterday harsh words against Israel, saying that Arabs serving in the police force is insulting and humiliating, and called on them to throw their weapons back in the faces of their officers and to resign. Arabs Israelis he said, should be a part of the Palestinians and work to overthrow the occupation. And he said more than that, but you get the idea.

I remember when just a few years ago Udah was the darling of Israeli society and media. He was looked at as someone who against all odds was promoting coexistence and partnership between Arabs and Jews.

And now the calls increase to investigate him for incitement to violence, for being a traitor, and the like. He showed himself to be more of a demon and less of the conciliatory figure he has portrayed himself as over the past few years.

It is sad that this is how it turned out, the other way would have been better, but better that it has been exposed. Better late than never.


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 13, 2021

Facebook Status of the Day

This is pretty disappointing, though many will not be surprised by it and have claimed all along that deep down this is what the Israeli Arabs believe, even if they do not say it openly.... and this is Israeli Arabs, with full citizenship and rights like all Jewish Israelis, including voting. Not like the Arabs in Judea and Samaria that don't have the same rights because they are residents but not citizens 









------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

how bad has it gotten?

How bad has this tiktokifada gotten?

As mentioned, Lod seems to be the worst but there has been bad violence in a number of towns around Israel, in addition to "random" and "spontaneous" violence on roads near Arab areas...

so how bad has it gotten, especially in Lod?

The news today has reported that it has gotten so bad in Lod that [some] Jewish residents have been removing the mezuzas from their doorposts so their buildings would not be identified as housing Jews.



This is reminiscent of the worst, the darkest, times in Jewish history when Jews had to hide their identity as Jews in order to survive. And sadly this is happening in a Jewish State under Jewish control, and the police and national leadership seem to be AWOL. Responsibility Without Blame at its best. That should be a hashtag - #responsibilitywithoutblame. I am going to tweet it.







------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Tamra's confusing behavior

Just two weeks ago Israel suffered a horrific tragedy when 45 people were crushed to death at a religious festival in Meron on Lag B'Omer. It is hard to call anything a bright point in such a horrific incident but one of the bright points was when the Arabs from a nearby town called Tamra provided water and food to Meron survivors. They set up stations offering free food and drink to thousands of evacuees as they were trying to make their way off the Meron mountain in the chaos.

Besides for that there were other bright spots, like the outpouring of love and empathy among nearly the entire Israeli public, regardless of sector, and thousands in towns all over Israel lined up and waited hours to donate blood for the injured.

For the purpose of this post, the part of this under discussion is the Arabs from Tamra (and elsewhere) who were sympathetic and loving, and showed an amazing level of coexistence and care.

This morning, amid all the reports of violence around the country over the past day, news reports, both the Times Of Israel and The New York Times, reported on the violence and pointed out the following incident - "In Tamra, an Arab mob attacked a man presumed to be Jewish and nearly beat him to death, according to an Arab paramedic who saved him" (excerpt from the NYT)

How can the Arab residents of Tamra be so caring, so neighborly, so empathetic, so warm, and then just two weeks later join violent riots, join the tiktokifada, against people who did them no harm? How could such kind and caring people just go and assault other people?

It might not be the same exact people in both incidents, but both were the "Arabs from Tamra". By Meron we assumed it was the entire town that came out to help. It seemed like it was the nature of the people there, the humanity.

How could we go from one to the other, and so quickly?

Which is the more accurate depiction of Tamra? I don't know, and right now I am not sure it matters. As I said yesterday, the decades of coexistence has been shattered in days and I am not sure how we will go back to trusting our other neighbors without starting over and giving it a bunch more decades of work...




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Apr 26, 2021

Quote of the Day

The Arabs are Israeli citizens, at least for now..

  -- MK Betzalel Smotritch (Hatzionut Hadatit), in the Knesset Arrangements Committee during the discussion about forming a new committee to be headed by MK Mansour Abbas (Raam) to be called The Committee for Arab Issues.




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Nov 29, 2020

Hamis Abulafia died and it didn't go unnoticed

Abulafia Bakery in Tel Aviv - Yafo is an interesting story. The bakery was opened in 1879 by an Arab baker, Masoud Abulafia (I have seen a variety of spellings of the Abulafia name and I do not know which, in English, is accurate, so I am just spelling it the easiest way of the options). The Abulafia bakery was very popular, eventually opening other branches, including a branch that is kosher mehadrin.

In 1969 the bakery began closing on Yom Kippur and Pesach. The story goes that a rabbi in Tel Aviv was concerned about Jews buying chametz during Pesach from the bakery and approached the owner, Sayeed Abulafia and asked what their profits are for the week of Pesach. Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Shtrouber agreed to pay Abulafia the profits for the week on condition the bakery would remain closed, and supposedly this arrangement continued for several years. At some point, Sayeed told Rabbi Shtrouber that it was unnecessary to continue the arrangement - Rabbi Shtrouber would not need to pay him to close the bakery as he has decided to close it anyway as they have seen nothing but blessings since deciding to close for Pesach. 

This decision has been in effect since then. Abulafia Bakery closes for Pesach, so as not to cause Jews to buy chametz on Pesach, even though they are an Arab owned bakery and it would be perfectly permissible for them to remain open.

One of the owners of Abulafuia Bakery, Hamis Abulafia, died this past week. Besides for his personal history of being pro-Israel and his history as a journalist and radio personality promoting good neighbor relations between the Arabs and Jews of Tel Aviv Yafo, Hamis and his brothers kept the original arrangement all these years by their own volition, and were clearly beloved for it. The various news sites, especially the Haredi news sites, all reported the death of Hamis, at the age of 60 years old, from Corona, with great respect. 

The Abulafia clearly did something good and were beloved for it. The fact that they did it on their own without pressure from the law and threats from the "establishment", makes it an even greater decision and made them more beloved and respected in the eyes of the public. Normally the death of an Arab baker would likely go unnoticed, if at all reported, but Hamis and his family have earned themselves a special place in the hearts of many Israelis.







------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Mar 10, 2020

Orly Levi Abuksis won't sit with the Arab party but didnt steal your vote

This evening MK Orly Levi Abuksis, currently a member of the unified list of parties Labor-Gesher-Meretz, upset a lot of people on the Left when she announced that she will not help Gantz form a government that includes reliance on the Joint Arab List.

People on the Left are upset, saying she has no right to do this, she is stealing their vote, this is not what they voted for her for, etc.

They have a right to be upset at her, just like every person has the right to be upset at any politician that lets him or her down - that does not live up to expectations, no matter how realistic those expectations were.

That being said, Orly Levi Abuksis did not steal anyone's vote. Perhaps had she made a specific promise on a given issue and went back on that with no reasonable explanation, perhaps she could be accused of stealing a vote. No matter who you might have voted for, it is extremely unlikely that you agree with that politician 100% on every issue. Whenever that politician does something you do not particularly agree with, you might accuse the politician of stealing your vote. That is not how it works - at least not in the political system of Israel. Perhaps if the politician made a specific promise that he or she reneged on, or if the politician did the opposite of what was "pledged" in the party platform, without a reasonable explanation, then you might argue your vote was stolen. In this case, Abuksis never made a pledge to sit with the Arab parties. Her deciding not to is not stealing the votes of her voters, and it is definitely not stealing the votes of people who did not vote for her and just don't like her decision. As a matter of fact, no government in the history of Israel has brought the Arab parties into the governing coalition, so unless she promised otherwise, which she did not, it is fair to assume that her default was to continue not sitting with them. No matter what other Left or social policies she might have spoken about and whatever other promises she might have made, it is fair to assume that her default was not bringing the Arabs into government, just like it was everyone else's default.

I get the disappointment. I get the feeling that she could help Gantz get rid of Bibi, at least temporarily, and she is not taking advantage of the opportunity. And that is fair. Going so far as to say she is stealing your vote by not doing something she never promised to do and nobody else before has ever done it, that is not fair. She does not deserve to be kicked out of politics because of it, though maybe she does for other reasons - I do not know. On this specific issue, Abuksis is not being unreasonable.



------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jan 29, 2020

Wadi Ara Arabs don't want to become Palestinians

The Arab towns of "The Triangle" region in Israel, such as Umm Al Fahm, Baqa Al Gharbiyya, Taibe and others, are upset with Trump's Deal of the Century.

Since the beginning of peace talks between the Palestinians and the Israelis, way back in the early 90s, The Arab towns in The Triangle region were always considered potentially for land swaps in an eventual agreement, with these Arab villages going to a new Palestinian State with other lands going to Israel. They always opposed it, despite their hard-core and even extremist and fundamentalist stances against Israel. The populations of these towns are not, generally, friendly and cooperative Israeli Arabs, as the residents of Abu Ghosh, for example, are. These are often Israeli Arabs that are somewhat hostile to Israel and to Israelis. Yet they have always said they wish to remain part of Israel.

And they are saying it again.

The representatives of these towns are speaking out against Trump's Deal of the Century because the Deal calls for them to be absorbed into a new Palestinian State that would be founded.

These Israeli Arabs want to stay part of Israel and not become Palestinians.
source: Ynet

And they have a good claim. They aren't Palestinian Arabs with refugee status or some other non-Israeli status. Despite their hostile environment, they are full Israeli citizens. I can understand why they do not want to give that up and become part of a Palestinian state.

That's how bad the corruption out there must be - even the biggest supporters only want it for other people, but not for themselves...


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jul 29, 2018

Dayeinu for the Nation State Law

The Nation State Law is really making waves. Even though it practically changes nothing, which makes one wonder why it was so necessary anyway, it has effected a wave of protests, and now last night MK Bahloul (Hamachaneh Hatzioni) announced, on live television during an interview with Rena Matzliach, that he will be resigning from the Knesset as he cannot stay in with such a law being passed on his clock.

Interestingly enough, Bahloul said he would submit his resignation to the Knesset at the end of the vacation period. That means that MK Bahloul, who is so deeply troubled by the passage of a specific law to the point that he cannot possibly stay in the Knesset and work from within to improve it or to change it or to bring down the government or whatever, has no problem taking 3 more months of salary for the 3 month vacation period of the Knesset and only resigning at the end of that. A man of very high scruples. He must truly be troubled by this law.

UAL, the United Arab List, has announced that its MKs are all considering resigning from the Knesset together, to make a point.

I do not know who the next 12 on the UAL list are, nor do I know their politics or style, but of these 12 I can think of a few that we will breathe a sigh of relief and say Baruch Shepitarani over their resignations... After all the efforts to get rid of a few of these MKs, all it took in the end is this Nation State Law.. and if that is all it accomplishes, dayeinu.



------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Dec 13, 2017

Quote of the Day

I would rather die than since the Israeli national anthem

  -- MK Jamal Zahalka (UAL)

ok... yaharog v'al yaavor...




------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jul 27, 2016

MK Aimen Udeh responds to Netanyahu's video to the Arabs (video)







------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jul 17, 2016

Balad's primary results decides Zoabi's fate

According to Channel 2 News, the Arab party for Knesset and member party of the United Arab List, Balad, has held its primaries and announced the results for the next elections, whenever they might be.

The results indicate that they have had enough of Hanin Zoabi and her antics that make them look bad. Zoabi has been pushed down to what is considered an unrealistic spot on the party list. Zoabi is now number 5 on the list, while the party currently holds 3 seats total.

The most noteworthy part of this news report, in my mind, is that Balad, the most extreme of the Arab parties, is more democratic in its functioning than most of the Jewish parties in the Knesset. Balad holds primaries to decide its party list while most other parties in the Knesset do not.


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Jun 29, 2016

Misrad Hapnim sponsoring trips to Har Habayit... for Arabs

The Ministry of the Interior is subsidizing transportation for Muslims from the Galilee area wanting to go to Al Aqsa on Temple Mount. The State-sponsored buses are free of charge for them.

Deri, the Minister of Interior, speaking at a Ramadan break-fast event, spoke about the need for peace between neighbors and living together in peace and with cooperation, and mutual respect.
source: Kikar

1. From a social perspective, and from a democratic society perspective, this is wonderful of the Misrad Hapnim to help them with their religious worship.

2. Are there similar programs for Jews wanting to visit the Kotel or Har Habayit? Are there similar programs for Christians wanting to visit the Church of the Holy Suplchre, or others?

3. I am sure Deri does not want to encourage Jews to visit Har Habayit, as he believes Jews should not be there, but shouldn't he also not encourage Arabs to visit? Arabs can be on Har Habayit, but they also go to areas that the Torah says non-kohanim cannot go. So the same problem Deri has with Jews being up there he should have with Arabs being up there. Being passive about it and not fighting for them to be banned form Har Habayit is one thing. Encouraging them to go by sponsoring free buses is another.






------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Oct 12, 2015

Arab mayor screams at Arab MK for ruining his city

the Arab mayor of Nazareth screams at Uman Aida for ruining his city because now no Jews are coming to it to spend the day, spend money and coexist




the mayor, Ali Salaam, had more to say and spoke to Globes about the problems and how the MKs are only making it worse and destroying the city...


------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

May 6, 2015

"Courage: The Reason I'm an Israeli-Arab Diplomat Not a Palestinian Refugee" (video)







------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

debut speeches of new MKs (video)

this is aa news report about the debut speeches of the new MKs.. the interesting part, to me, i s at 1:55 - I so far like the style of MK Uman Aydeh, head of the Joint Arab List. After his speech Eichler started his speech with a bit in Arabic, praising and welcoming Aydeh.





------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Mar 24, 2015

Netanyahu apologizes to Arab leaders (video)

Netanyahu graciously apologizes for his words, and gets cheered. The standing ovation he gets here is probably more valuable than the many standing ovations he got in Congress a couple of weeks back...





------------------------------------------------------
Reach thousands of readers with your ad by advertising on Life in Israel
------------------------------------------------------

Related Posts

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...